Jump to content
Al Brown

Summicron M 50 (IV and V) vs. Hexanon M 50

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Advertisement (gone after registration)

Please share your opinion - if you have used or owned both lenses or any opinion on the topic. Mostly interested in comparison of render, sharpness, bokeh, pop etc. according to you - digital sensor or film.

Early reports indicated the Hexanons were inferior. According to LHSA "some Hexanon early samples were reported to have focusing discrepancies, long since resolved, and that adversely affected initial sales. The current consensus: Konica KM and Leica M lenses, even those with longer focal lengths and wider apertures, can be used interchangeably on both cameras without problems." Lots of posts ot the tiny flange difference between the cameras, but here we discuss the lens.

Mr. Rockwell even went as far as comparing the build of Summicron 50 (V) to the Hexanon-M 50 side by side and they indeed look almost identical. Check the pic on his webpage under the Hexanon topic.
I have recently acquired a Hexanon-M 50/2 (photographed below on my M) and it is a stellar performer, slightly better wide open (especially corners) compared to Summicron M 50/2 (IV) in all the tests I did.

YMMV.

Edited by Al Brown

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, Al Brown said:

Please share your opinion......
Mr. Rockwell even went as far as comparing the build of Summicron 50 (V) to the Hexanon-M 50 side by side and they indeed look almost identical.......
I have recently acquired a Hexanon-M 50/2......and it is a stellar performer, slightly better wide open......compared to Summicron M 50/2 (IV) in all the tests I did...

Interesting to read about your experience with the pair, Al. I've never even seen one of the Hexanons in 'real-life' (not that I've tried hard to find one) let alone had the chance to compare one with my V4 Summicron but I did read Mr. Rockwell's review a few years ago and didn't remember him having had such a positive experience as yourself. I've just re-read it and his opening comments are;

"This Konica lens is more than capable of creating fantastic images. If you're counting pixels, its performance is clearly inferior to the Leica Summicron 50mm f2 (i.e. the 1979 - 2013 V4 and V5 optical formula) which this Konica does its best to imitate.".

Ken Rockwell, of course, has his well-known antipathy to most non-Leica  offerings - certain Zeiss optics excepted - so this prejudice must always be taken into account when considering his expressed views! As I said earlier; I doubt I'll ever get the chance to compare the two but you seem to be very happy with your sample and perhaps that is the only thing which matters? Enjoy it!

Philip.

Edited by pippy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

M-Hexanon 2/50mm ...

This is one of the "secret not to be diffused lens".

More than ten years ago, I had opportunity to buy one cheap second hand ( as usual, I told myself 'if it's not good, just sell it after trying').

But still now I always keep it as it's a very nice performer and "cheap for what it offers", not far less than Cron IV/V,

but in some cases it's not up to Summicron lenses that I have.

Mine has very small discrepency on RF coupling with Leica M bodies, but works nicely on Konica Hexar RF,

so I've done nothing to "repair" it.

I must use it a bit more 🙂.

 

When I use it on Monochrom, it's very nice, only the filter size is E40.5, that bother me as I must use adapters for colored filters that I have.

Sliding hood is too short (as on 50 Cron V, I mount screw-in hood for better contre-jour control) and focussing ring is a bit "sharp" for my delicate digits.

 

In the same M-Hexanon, I have also 2/35 and 2.8/28 that can be used without any fear.

They are as good performer as Leica lenses of same period and specifications.

 

 

Edited by a.noctilux

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Al,

I haven't used the M-Hexanon 50/2 but I do have the Dual M-Hexanon 21/35 and it is an excellent performer.  I don't compare lenses because every comparison is subjective and will in some way coloured by the reviewers likes/dislikes preferences, or perhaps even sponsor's wishes.

The Hexanon's have a reputation for excellent build quality, which doubtless you will already be aware of with your 50/2.

The one area where the Summicron IV and V sometimes struggle is flare when shooting into the light.  You might try your Hexanon into the light and see if you're satisfied with its performance.  If you are then perhaps you will have answered the question.

Pete.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
vor 11 Stunden schrieb Al Brown:

 Konica KM and Leica M lenses, even those with longer focal lengths and wider apertures, can be used interchangeably on both cameras without problems.

That's right.

.

vor 11 Stunden schrieb Al Brown:

 Lots of posts ot the tiny flange difference between the cameras ...

That's a common misconception. In fact, there is no difference in the flange distances between the cameras. Instead, there just is a difference in the defiitions what 'flange distance' is supposed to be. Effectively, they're the same.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Advertisement (gone after registration)

Also on this topic - I do not know if anyone is really interested, but I successfully coded the lens to Summicron 50 (III) 11817 which is 010111.
It was impossible to code to Summicron (IV) or (V) which is 100001 because the screw was recognised by Leica's 6-bit reader as one of the black bars (as you know the white bars do not matter much). So I opted for the next best thing. It is also recommended by La Vida Leica website for M-Hexanon to code as Summicron (III) but I am not sure about this, as the lens seems identical to Summicron (V) in build. Anyway, I chose the only possible approach and the procedure was relatively hassle free. I have a foolproof 6-bit coding system that starts with Sellotape, continues through trial and error with Sharpie and ends in permanent acrylic black paint. See the attached photo.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Al Brown said:

Also on this topic - I do not know if anyone is really interested, but I successfully coded the lens to Summicron 50 (III) 11817 which is 010111.
It was impossible to code to Summicron (IV) or (V) which is 100001 because the screw was recognised by Leica's 6-bit reader as one of the black bars (as you know the white bars do not matter much). So I opted for the next best thing. It is also recommended by La Vida Leica website for M-Hexanon to code as Summicron (III) but I am not sure about this, as the lens seems identical to Summicron (V) in build. Anyway, I chose the only possible approach and the procedure was relatively hassle free. I have a foolproof 6-bit coding system that starts with Sellotape, continues through trial and error with Sharpie and ends in permanent acrylic black paint. See the attached photo.

Filling that summicron crew with a little white paint works too.

Edited by jdlaing

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 3/10/2020 at 5:11 AM, Al Brown said:

 

Also on this topic - I do not know if anyone is really interested, but I successfully coded the lens to Summicron 50 (III) 11817 which is 010111.
It was impossible to code to Summicron (IV) or (V) which is 100001 because the screw was recognised by Leica's 6-bit reader as one of the black bars (as you know the white bars do not matter much). So I opted for the next best thing. It is also recommended by La Vida Leica website for M-Hexanon to code as Summicron (III) but I am not sure about this, as the lens seems identical to Summicron (V) in build. Anyway, I chose the only possible approach and the procedure was relatively hassle free. I have a foolproof 6-bit coding system that starts with Sellotape, continues through trial and error with Sharpie and ends in permanent acrylic black paint. See the attached photo.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Coding the M-Hexanon 50/2 as Summicron 50/2 v3 or v4 doesn't change anything but exif data in my experience, at least on my M240 and digital CL.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
53 minutes ago, lct said:

Coding the M-Hexanon 50/2 as Summicron 50/2 v3 or v4 doesn't change anything but exif data in my experience, at least on my M240 and digital CL.

It also removes the hassle of "NO LENS" message during live view, and EXIF is a good thing, no?

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
31 minutes ago, Al Brown said:

It also removes the hassle of "NO LENS" message during live view, and EXIF is a good thing, no?

Depends on the body i guess. On my digital CL the lens is recognized as Tele-Elmarit 90/2.8, don't ask me why. This way i know that i was not using a Summicron at least. Otherwise it is a fine lens indeed. It is not flare free but it has less flare than the current Summicron 50/2 non apo, especially when strong light sources are outside the frame. The Hexanon has less focus shift too. My copy # 3216*** suffers from back focus on the M240 though but it is not a problem on mirrorless cameras. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Tuvok75
      Verkaufe nach langer Überlegung nun doch meine schöne Leica Monochrom Typ 246, schwarz, 1. Hand, gebraucht, technisch einwandfrei, sehr leichte, minimale Gebrauchspuren, inkl. Originalverpackung. Erworben direkt bei Leica Camera in Wetzlar.  
      Verkauf OHNE Objektiv, mit Originalgurt.
      Weitere Fotos sende ich gerne per E-Mail zu.
      Preis 3650,-€ zzgl. Versand ung ggf. Paypalgebühren
      Verkauf nur innerhalb von Deutschland.
      Abholung und ausführliche Test sind gerne möglich und erwünscht, Ort: Nähe Gießen/ Hessen / Deutschland

      Fragen beantworte ich gerne per PN.

      Wie üblich beim Privatverkauf übernehme/gewähre ich keine Garantie, Gewährleistung, Umtausch, Rücknahme u. Ä






    • By SaW
      Hello,
      I'm selling a superb Leica 50mm Apo Summicron - M Black Chrome limited edition lens.
      This lens has been purchased new on 01/02/2020 and used for less than 50 photos so it is completely new, free from any mark of use.
      It is under warranty until 01/02/2022 and sold complete with all accessories and original Leica luxury box.
       
      This lens becomes difficult to find new or in second hand and its price is rising: (f.i.: launched at us$9700 list price it is now proposed by B&H at $10500 and there's only a few items left).
      I purchased it because I wanted to have a collector item from Leica and because I knew the price of limited edition models is going up with the time.
      But I have no Leica M camera anymore and then decided not to leave this beautiful lens on the shelf for years.
      My asking price is the exact same price I paid for it. I could benefit from a nice 12% discount that you can also benefit from.
       
      International shipping is possible but only using UPS + fully ensured value (I'm located in Brussels, Belgium).
      Sales of 2nd hand items between private persons usually means no customs and sales taxes to be paid at the US customs. 
      I just sold a Leica S007 camera in California to a forum member and can provide references of past sales with perfect feedback from the buyer. 
       
      Thanks for watching,
       
      Vincent
       




    • By willeica
      I am posting this here and in the Collectors and Historica section of the Forum. I will give a Zoom presentation for the LHSA at 7.30 pm, British Summer Time, 2.30pm EDT, on 19th August 2020 about 'Choosing and Using Old Leicas'. A link to register for the talk, which is free for LHSA - The International Leica Society – members, is here. 
       https://lhsa.org/2020/06/free-webinar-aug-19-choosing-and-using-old-leicas-with-willian-fagan/#myaccount
       The talk , while mainly aimed at those with smaller collections and photographers who want to have one or two old or vintage Leica cameras to use, will also be of interest to more experienced collectors and users.
       ‘Old Leicas’ will include LTM and M models from 1925 up to and including the M6. I will present Leicas from different generations in groups of 3 and will indicate my own personal favourites, which should give rise to varied opinions in the discussion afterwards.

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in to view the hidden content. Hallo Gast! Du willst die Bilder sehen? Einfach registrieren oder anmelden! I will indicate some of my favourite films. I will also give tips about using older Leica cameras, in particular about the question of loading LTM models and film trimming in advance of loading.

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in to view the hidden content. Hallo Gast! Du willst die Bilder sehen? Einfach registrieren oder anmelden! I will describe various accessories for Leica cameras and their uses such as viewfinders, lens hoods, winders, cases, close-up equipment and filters.

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in to view the hidden content. Hallo Gast! Du willst die Bilder sehen? Einfach registrieren oder anmelden! The response to this has been very good, with 135 members from many different countries registered as of yesterday, indicating the increasing interest in vintage Leicas and film photography generally. There are still a number of places available. We hope to have some time for questions and answers afterwards. I hope to see some forum members online as I know that quite a few here are LHSA members.
      William
       
       
       
       
    • By willeica
      I am posting this here and in the LHSA section of the Forum. I will give a Zoom presentation for the LHSA at 7.30 pm, British Summer Time, 2.30pm EDT, on 19th August 2020 about 'Choosing and Using Old Leicas'. A link to register for the talk, which is free for LHSA - The International Leica Society – members, is here. 
       https://lhsa.org/2020/06/free-webinar-aug-19-choosing-and-using-old-leicas-with-willian-fagan/#myaccount
       The talk , while mainly aimed at those with smaller collections and photographers who want to have one or two old or vintage Leica cameras to use, will also be of interest to more experienced collectors and users.
       ‘Old Leicas’ will include LTM and M models from 1925 up to and including the M6. I will present Leicas from different generations in groups of 3 and will indicate my own personal favourites, which should give rise to varied opinions in the discussion afterwards.

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in to view the hidden content. Hallo Gast! Du willst die Bilder sehen? Einfach registrieren oder anmelden! I will indicate some of my favourite films. I will also give tips about using older Leica cameras, in particular about the question of loading LTM models and film trimming in advance of loading.

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in to view the hidden content. Hallo Gast! Du willst die Bilder sehen? Einfach registrieren oder anmelden! I will describe various accessories for Leica cameras and their uses such as viewfinders, lens hoods, winders, cases, close-up equipment and filters.

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in to view the hidden content. Hallo Gast! Du willst die Bilder sehen? Einfach registrieren oder anmelden! The response to this has been very good, with 135 members from many different countries registered as of yesterday, indicating the increasing interest in vintage Leicas and film photography generally. There are still a number of places available. We hope to have some time for questions and answers afterwards. I hope to see some forum members online as I know that quite a few here are LHSA members.
      William
       
       
       
    • By Al Brown
      Just came from Latvia on assignment and got me a little souvenir... noticing how similar their Laima chocolate company logo is to Leica's. What do you think? Does any other company have a similar logo?

      Hello guest! Please register or sign in to view the hidden content. Hallo Gast! Du willst die Bilder sehen? Einfach registrieren oder anmelden!
×
×
  • Create New...