Jump to content

Dillon, Colorado 11-21-2006


davidmires

Recommended Posts

Thanks, everyone, for taking the time to comment.

 

Brent, the trees in the foreground are affected by "beetle kill". The pine beetle kills great numbers of trees here, and they are reddish. I think what you are seeing is a combination of that redness and the color from the sky. I have not had a problem with magenta outdoors, and rarely indoors. Only under artificial light, and only with certain fabrics. Certainly not a deal-breaker IMO. (On a side note, the banding issue is problematic if you are going to shoot the city, or indoors, at night... this needs to be fixed!) The camera is brilliant, and you really have to use it, and view the prints, to see how good it really is. The magenta problem is real, but it isn't as big a deal as has been made of it on the web.

 

The colors in this photo were accurately rendered, as far as my eyes can tell.

 

Cheers, David.

Link to post
Share on other sites

David,

 

Lovely shot. My initial reaction was that there's an overall slight magenta shift / haziness to the image. But after reading your above post, it certainly could be attributed to the lighting. For the record, almost any Nikon DSLR I've used has had subtle to noticeable magenta shifts...this is not an M8 only issue.

 

I've got to get out West again....thanks for posting.

 

- Dan

Link to post
Share on other sites

Brent, and Dan,

On second look, I think you are right about the magenta cast.

I did a quick color cast adjustment in photoshop, and it looks better to me.

For some reason, I usually can't see a color cast until I have a print...

Thanks for the input.

David,

 

Lovely shot. My initial reaction was that there's an overall slight magenta shift / haziness to the image. But after reading your above post, it certainly could be attributed to the lighting. For the record, almost any Nikon DSLR I've used has had subtle to noticeable magenta shifts...this is not an M8 only issue.

 

I've got to get out West again....thanks for posting.

 

- Dan

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks, everyone, for taking the time to comment.

 

Brent, the trees in the foreground are affected by "beetle kill". The pine beetle kills great numbers of trees here, and they are reddish. I think what you are seeing is a combination of that redness and the color from the sky. I have not had a problem with magenta outdoors, and rarely indoors. Only under artificial light, and only with certain fabrics. Certainly not a deal-breaker IMO. (On a side note, the banding issue is problematic if you are going to shoot the city, or indoors, at night... this needs to be fixed!) The camera is brilliant, and you really have to use it, and view the prints, to see how good it really is. The magenta problem is real, but it isn't as big a deal as has been made of it on the web.

 

The colors in this photo were accurately rendered, as far as my eyes can tell.

 

Cheers, David.

 

Thanks very much, David. I'm still eagerly awaiting my M8! I've seen far more breathtaking shots from the M8 than problem images. I know the issues are real but have every confidence they will be fixed.

 

Regards,

Link to post
Share on other sites

David,

 

Well done! I often find in my own case, that working with digital RAW files - I tend to get a slight magenta cast, and a slight decrease in contrast upon final import into Photoshop. A quick correction, and it usually snaps.

Link to post
Share on other sites

David -

 

I like them both, but prefer the romance of the first. Both retain their wonderful cloud patterns. If all things were prefect I'd like the trees in the foreground a bit lighter, but that's beyond my post production skills.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks again, for the kind remarks and advice!

 

Stuart, I tried a version with the trees in the foreground much lighter, but I didn't like it. It looked much too unnatural, and overly "photoshopped". I think it needs to be somewhat dark to preserve the early evening mood.

 

Cheers, David.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Wonderful shot! With it being near 80 and sunny in Texas today, it is nice to see that some areas are still seasonable. The color and light is very impressive. Funny that earlier today I was browsing through a book that was given to me back in 2000 where a modern photographer, John Reynolds I think was the name, reshot a lot of shots of Colorado done by W.H. Jackson in the late 1800s. The photos were placed side by side so as to compare the changes over time. Dillon was the subject of several photographs. Great area.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Paul - I know the book, I bought a copy for my brother when it came out. I would like to find a smaller version of the book, to take in the car with me. I think it would be fun to visit the places with the book in hand to better get a feel for how they looked 100 years ago.

 

Rolo - Thanks for taking the time to comment.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...