X1 Challenge #1 - Harmony - VOTE HERE

[andybarton]

Advertisement (gone after registration)

I think that both mezner's entries should be excluded. It's not fair to every other entrant.

 

Sorry

[timd.]

too bad - i really do like 'the harmony of chaos'

 

 

by the way: interesting to find so many new forum participants taking part in the challenge. maybe doing things like this is a good way to attract new members!

[bill]

Tim, thank you for spotting this.

 

I agree with Andy. The rules are clear. It is unfortunate that we have not picked this up before voting started.

 

Therefore:

 

1. For the avoidance of doubt, BOTH Meznar's entries will be excluded from further voting

 

2. Those people who have already cast a vote for his image (that is specifically Wattsy, Andybarton, Archsnapper, Giordano, Boddhi, Tim Delbeck) may recast their votes. If they choose not to, their first choices will stand, minus the votes for Meznar.

 

Regards,

 

Bill

[pico]

fotografr, 3 points

Kjell Martin, 2 points

msbel, 1 point

[andybarton]

I will remove both of the entries in question.

[wolffmeister]

my votes are:

 

-> Firesuite : 3 points

-> Phenic :2 Points

-> Santdtman : 1 Point

[andybarton]

Advertisement (gone after registration)

First choice "fotografr" - 3 points

Second choice "firesuite" - 2 points

Third choice "meznar" - 1 point (The curtains shot. I believe the second shot with the dog should be removed as the challenge is for one shot only)

 

Third choice is now "wolffmeister"- 1 point

[John Thawley]

Martin 3pts

Craft 2pts

Firesuite 1pts

[J_Thompson]

Martin - 3 points

archsnapper - 2 points

fotografr - 1 point

[cbretteville]

Well done all!

 

My votes:

 

firesuite - 3 points

fotografr - 2 points

phenic - 1 point

 

Carl

[regedit]

fotografr: 3p

wolffmeister: 2p

Kjell Martin: 1p

 

congrats to all participants. nice work for everyone!

[meznar]

Dear Moderator

 

i apologize for the wrong understanding of rules. If i wanted to cheat, i would sign up under

two different usernames. If i would be warned before the voting started, i would gladly remove one photo.

However, i am still very thankful to all members that voted for my photo - it is a great confirmation for me that i

am going the right way. Even though now i can't get the prize. :-)

 

Meznar

[RockyIII]

First choice - Kjell Martin - 3 pts.

Second choice - Clemgill - 2 pts.

Third choice - craft - 1 pt.

 

Rocky

[Douglasco]

3 points fotografr

 

2 points craft

 

1 point msbel

[box477]

Craft - 3 points

Kjjell Martin - 2 points

Firesuite - 1point

[phancj]

My vote

 

First place (Fotografr) : 3 pts

Second place (Firesuite): 2 pts

Third Place (Kjell Martin): 1 pt

 

I feel that Meznar's both entries are phenomenal, what a pity....I especially dig that curtain shot, incredible composition, technical and artistic mastery, I really do hope Meznar will compete in future...my wife picked that as her first choice!

 

I think most of the entries are great, it was tough deciding for me...

 

I think I'll shoot for the next challenge to be extended in terms of the shooting period to include all across the festive period xmas, New Year...that way we'll have loads of time to make killer shots. Still learning this contest organization thingy, kudos to Bill for his kind help always and Andy too!

 

CJ

[brill64]

1. Craft - 3pnts

2. Mattnnz - 2pnts

3. MartinMann - 1pnt

[ChiILX1]

First choice [Craft] - 3 points

Second choice [Kjell Martin]- 2 points

Third choice [Firesuite] - 1 point

[Graf Lomo]

Here are my votes:

 

1. wolffmeister | Back2Back - 3 points

2. fotografr | Orchestra pit - 2 points

3. Kjell Martin | Opera in Oslo - 1 point

 

Very good entrys there. So this was a hard choice. Good luck to all.

[Advertisement]

Hallo,

Look here: Interesting Leica gear

[LeicaBraz]

Since I did not vote for the third place, this is just to add that my third vote goes to:

 

Firesuite (1 pt)

 

Tks+sorry