Jump to content

Sean Reid - Nose Job


ziggurat

Recommended Posts

Advertisement (gone after registration)

Hi,

 

I just read Sean Reid's article on Luminous Landscape.

 

I agree with him that the M8 is comfortable to put to the eye. However the bit sticking out from the USB port cover makes my nose sore.

 

Anyone else think it could be shifted? It's still there on the M9.

 

Cheers

Johnny

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hmm ... sounds like there's an up-side to being left-eyed after all.:p

 

Pete.

Hi Pete

 

When you go vertical (with your MP) it may be convenient to use the left eye and forehead to stabilise the camera.

I'm sorta left eyed but I use the right eye when horizontal, cause I dont close the left...

 

Noel

Link to post
Share on other sites

Advertisement (gone after registration)

Hi,

 

I also read Sean’s article in which he again mentions the well known problem of the interference we make as photographers having a "machine" between us and our subject. He states:

 

There's a second benefit to having an eyepiece on the left side of the camera. With a central eyepiece, the photographer's face is largely hidden behind the camera. The camera physically intercedes between the photographer and his or her subject. Some feel that this can be somewhat disturbing to human subjects who, when photographed, are looking more at a machine than at a human face. But when the camera sits alongside the nose and against the right eye, much of one's face is visible to the subject.

 

This often discussed fact inspired me to make a quick test and directly compare the two situations from the point of a potential subject. So I took my M8 and my DLSR, took a mirror, went out in the garden and simulated photographing a fictive person passing by. I even tried to communicate with the person by facing him or her directly.

 

I was surprised how big I felt the difference was – look for yourself.

 

Best

Holger

 

 

M8 | Summicron 2/75 | ISO 160 | 1/360 | f/6.7

Welcome, dear visitor! As registered member you'd see an image here…

Simply register for free here – We are always happy to welcome new members!

 

 

Pentax K5 | DA 2.4/70 limited | ISO 140 | 1/250 | f/6.7

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi,

 

I also read Sean’s article in which he again mentions the well known problem of the interference we make as photographers having a "machine" between us and our subject. He states:

 

There's a second benefit to having an eyepiece on the left side of the camera. With a central eyepiece, the photographer's face is largely hidden behind the camera. The camera physically intercedes between the photographer and his or her subject. Some feel that this can be somewhat disturbing to human subjects who, when photographed, are looking more at a machine than at a human face. But when the camera sits alongside the nose and against the right eye, much of one's face is visible to the subject.

 

This often discussed fact inspired me to make a quick test and directly compare the two situations from the point of a potential subject. So I took my M8 and my DLSR, took a mirror, went out in the garden and simulated photographing a fictive person passing by. I even tried to communicate with the person by facing him or her directly.

 

I was surprised how big I felt the difference was – look for yourself.

 

Best

Holger

 

 

Damn, then I'm out. I'm left eyed and constantly staining the LCD with my greasy nose :(

 

Bruno

Link to post
Share on other sites

Holger,

 

Thank you for posting these shots, which illustrate the problem very well. Unfortunately (for me) I believe the theory for rangefinder cameras only holds for right-eyed shooters because left-eyed shooters' faces will be even more hidden than is shown in your photo using a dSLR.:(

 

Interestingly perhaps, I note that with your dSLR you're forced to tilt your head down to accommodate your nose, which gives you a slightly sinister look.

 

Pete.

Link to post
Share on other sites

A waist level finder or swivel live view LCD on a DSLR helps if you want to capture discreetly.

 

I also remember a post by Sean on the Rangefinder Forum when he used an angle viewfinder with his Epson digital rangefinder to take images from around a corner!

 

Not so much street photography more like espionage!:D

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...