Jump to content

Passage


Steve Ricoh

Recommended Posts

Another interesting photo, Steve.  Like the photo on which I commented previously, this, too, has effective elements of geometry and scale.  I'd group it together with the B&W shot that you posted just a few days ago as part of a theme on geometry/scale-centric composition.  The B&W is ok but I like the color palette of the first.  Of course, this is not on the same level as if it were a color film shot (and you should consider a film M in due course).  But for what it is it is lovely and I commend you.  

I highly doubt the rendition that you've achieve came straight out of the camera like thais, so I commend you PP as well.  

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Adam for your comments and for acting as a sounding board. Coincidentally, my wife favoured the colour (color) version,  but I'm aware that the Flickr community seems to have a preference for B/W, a sort of cult following, and this can sway one's judgement. But as you say the colour palette has a value which is immediately lost when converted to monochrome, so my internal pendulum has swung over to agree with both you and my Mrs.

 

Funny that you should mention a film M, guess what I've been doing for the past week or two! I really fancy an MP, but think an M6 is more affordable. The idea will have to percolate for a while, but if a good deal turns up then I may join the club.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Adam for your comments and for acting as a sounding board. Coincidentally, my wife favoured the colour (color) version,  but I'm aware that the Flickr community seems to have a preference for B/W, a sort of cult following, and this can sway one's judgement. But as you say the colour palette has a value which is immediately lost when converted to monochrome, so my internal pendulum has swung over to agree with both you and my Mrs.

 

Funny that you should mention a film M, guess what I've been doing for the past week or two! I really fancy an MP, but think an M6 is more affordable. The idea will have to percolate for a while, but if a good deal turns up then I may join the club.

Above all, the wife is ALWAYS right.  

Even putting this aside, I think that effective color go a long way on Flickr, provided it is put before the right crowd.  I quite frankly am lost on most of the B&W "street"-type photography on Flickr.  A bunch of people lost in a quid pro quo social loop de loop.  Trust you instincts - and above all those of your wife!!

Completely understand the percolation on the film; and by no means to you need to splurge for an M6.  My first M was an (obviously) old M3, and it takes the same photos as my year-old M-A, which takes the same photos as my ancient IIIg, which take the same photos as my M7.  It's all good!

Now film choices are a different matter; we'll get to that later...

Link to post
Share on other sites

Steve,

 

perfect frame. You captured the dainty range of colour so well that the B&W Version cannot mirror even if it is also very good. I like the shades of blue and the texture of the glass. The golden light makes it very Special.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Steve, I very much like this shot and the way you framed it. I really can't tell which one I prefer; I find different interesting feel in each!

I couldn't make my mind up either, so put both up for comment. Both have a value in their own way, I suppose, but the feedback I'm getting shows a preference for colour.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Great perspective, light and colors! Yes, I prefer the color version.

 

Tibor

Thank you, I saw this elevated passage from a distance ( I was below it) and knew what I wanted before arriving at the scene. It was a case of waiting for the right person to come through. Probably spent half an hour waiting!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe the B&W conversion should be reworked to bring some detail from the very dark portions of the image, specially on her face. The color version is another story. a beauty.

Thank you for the feedback, Rodrigue. I'll play around with the B/W and see if I can bring out the tones - I'm sure I can, the Leica file has SO much detail, it's amazing. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...