Jump to content

So Confused! X1 or DSLR


chrispatel

Recommended Posts

Advertisement (gone after registration)

Well, I put my money where my mouth is and bought a GF1 (+ 20mm lens) today... It is not a replacement for either of my cameras, but I've been wanting to try it for an extended period of time since it came out. I bought it used at a decent price and I will just sell it when I'm done (if I don't care for it). I'm gonna put that AF to the test.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 78
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Well, I put my money where my mouth is and bought a GF1 (+ 20mm lens) today... It is not a replacement for either of my cameras, but I've been wanting to try it for an extended period of time since it came out. I bought it used at a decent price and I will just sell it when I'm done (if I don't care for it). I'm gonna put that AF to the test.

 

Keep us posted about the results (both AF and IQ). I am thinking of getting a GF1 too. I will be keeping my X1, of course.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I am sure the gf1 is great however I recommend to also look at the E-P2. My wife has a gh1 and I later got the E-p2 for myself before getting the x1.

X1 my favorite but I really do like the E-P2.

I think the inbody stabilization is great, and the EVF of the E-P2 is very good too.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I am sure the gf1 is great however I recommend to also look at the E-P2. My wife has a gh1 and I later got the E-p2 for myself before getting the x1.

X1 my favorite but I really do like the E-P2.

I think the inbody stabilization is great, and the EVF of the E-P2 is very good too.

 

+1 on the Pens

 

After racking my brain for several months as to whether to get the X1 or something else, I noticed (here in the UK) sellouts on the discontinued E-P1, and got one last week with 17mm f2.8 with optical finder for £380 where they were selling a few weeks ago for well over £600. So far I am very pleased with the IQ and operation and it really suits me, and I've saved a huge bundle of money so won't be getting an X1 now. The other advantage for me is that when I get the lens adapter I can use all my Zuiko 4/3 lenses for occasional use, though I have a feeling the 17mm will be staying on most of the time as its a great combination.

 

Nigel

Link to post
Share on other sites

Advertisement (gone after registration)

EP-1 discontinued already! I can't keep up. A year really is a long time in a digital life cycle. Who can possibly afford all this new technology? Hundreds or thousands of dollars a time. I reckon lenses are a good investment -- so long as there will still be a body around to fit them. Quite a few for the GF-1/G1/EP series now by the look of it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

EP-1 discontinued already! I can't keep up. A year really is a long time in a digital life cycle. Who can possibly afford all this new technology? Hundreds or thousands of dollars a time. I reckon lenses are a good investment -- so long as there will still be a body around to fit them. Quite a few for the GF-1/G1/EP series now by the look of it.

 

Yes, product life seems very short in the photographic world. But just because its been discontinued doesn't mean its useless - who would have thought many of us would still be raving about the Digilux 2 years after it left the shops. Most people need the newest and most technically advanced equipment available in the mistaken impression that it will make them take better photographs, which is rarely the case.

 

Nigel

Link to post
Share on other sites

EP-1 discontinued already! I can't keep up. A year really is a long time in a digital life cycle. Who can possibly afford all this new technology? Hundreds or thousands of dollars a time. I reckon lenses are a good investment -- so long as there will still be a body around to fit them. Quite a few for the GF-1/G1/EP series now by the look of it.

 

You are correct about lenses in the main. I can still use my 50 year old lenses on my new cameras, and in most cases my new lenses on my 50 year old camera. :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

I am sure the gf1 is great however I recommend to also look at the E-P2. My wife has a gh1 and I later got the E-p2 for myself before getting the x1.

X1 my favorite but I really do like the E-P2.

I think the inbody stabilization is great, and the EVF of the E-P2 is very good too.

 

I had the E-P1 before the X1. It was cool, but I think I'll enjoy the panasonic and its 20mm lens more. Plus, I still find the GF1 to have faster AF than the Pens (even with their update). So, for the Pens, been there, done that... needed to try something different.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok, been using the GF1 for the last two days and I have to admit something... the AF isn't as fast as I remember it to be. I'm using the 20mm lens and apparently, the zoom is faster. That said, the GF1's 20mm lens focuses fast if you keep focusing on things that are only a few inches to feet apart. However, focus on something up close and then 10 feet away and it is slow. That is where I see the big difference between an DSLR and the GF1. Everything else that is said about the camera is true as well. Its high ISO isn't that good and the shutter is noisy, but the IQ from the 20mm is very nice (and nice bokeh) and the LCD is great. If the X1 didn't exist... I'd be cool with this as my only bring everywhere camera. Overall, it is a nice camera for the money.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I can tell you, I regret selling my D700 and only having the X1 now.

 

First, you can hardly find a replacement to a great camera like the D700 to be honest.

Second, there're things you have to shoot with a DSLR, e.g. moving cars.

 

The X1 is great but I do miss the fast AF on my D700, when I need it.

 

If you can, keep the D700 and get a X1. That'll be perfect!

 

That's what I'm saving for now. To get the D700 back.

Link to post
Share on other sites

First, you can hardly find a replacement to a great camera like the D700 to be honest.

Second, there're things you have to shoot with a DSLR, e.g. moving cars...

 

The M series works well too... :)

 

I downgraded from a D700 to a Leica M8.2 and could not be happier.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Fascinating... Why?

 

Because I'm a die-hard rangefinder user... it's a comfort thing for me (having used an M6 and Contax G for so many years). I tried to say to myself that I wanted the best image making machine I could afford... so I tried the D700 (having sold my original M8 to afford it). The photos look technically great, but I was no longer inspired and didn't feel right using it (and my images changed for the worse). Once I got the M8.2 and sold the D700, the inspired feeling came back and my photos got better. Sure, this is my own opinion and based on my silly little idiosyncrasies... but I'd rather have the most comfortable tool than the best tool.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I would go for the X1 without hesitation; in fact I am about to get one myself after having been very dissapointed with loads of so called great compacts: GF1, PEN EP-1, GRDIII, G11. Don't get me wrong they all produce good files, but the Leica experience goes beyond anything that is easily explainable.

 

DSLRs are great when you have the time to lug them around, but they are just not practical for general use (IMO)

 

And of course the other issues is that when you do finally buy a Leica it is then very hard to go back. I have the M8 and some nice Leica lenses and I just can't bear being without them - unless of course I upgrade!

Link to post
Share on other sites

there are plus'es and minus'es lots of them both ways and one can argue about them until oblivion .... and most arguments would have some sense of truth in them.

 

I like the X1 because it produces very nice images, and I can slip it into the pocket of my Camel safari jackets, it's easy to operate and very inconspicuous. Thats all I needed, OVF, EVF, Chimping etc all becomes irrelevant for me ....

Link to post
Share on other sites

there are plus'es and minus'es lots of them both ways and one can argue about them until oblivion .... and most arguments would have some sense of truth in them.

 

I like the X1 because it produces very nice images, and I can slip it into the pocket of my Camel safari jackets, it's easy to operate and very inconspicuous. Thats all I needed, OVF, EVF, Chimping etc all becomes irrelevant for me ....

 

Totally agree:

Portability+Great IQ=complete satisfaction:D

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...