Q3 or 28 Summilux?

[Hoya]

Advertisement (gone after registration)

Trying to decide between buying a Q3 or a 28 Summilux. I have a M-10R with a mix of Lux and Chrons at 35, 50, 75, and 90. Bought a 28 1.4 Thypoch Simera and fell in love with the focal length (the lens is also an amazing value for the $) - so also a question about whether a marginal improvement in the lens is worth the cost to add Leica glass at that length. Thanks for insights.

[3D-Kraft.com]

vor 15 Minuten schrieb Hoya:

so also a question about whether a marginal improvement in the lens is worth the cost to add Leica glass at that length.

What makes you sure, that you'll have that?

[helged]

22 minutes ago, Hoya said:

Trying to decide between buying a Q3 or a 28 Summilux. I have a M-10R with a mix of Lux and Chrons at 35, 50, 75, and 90. Bought a 28 1.4 Thypoch Simera and fell in love with the focal length (the lens is also an amazing value for the $) - so also a question about whether a marginal improvement in the lens is worth the cost to add Leica glass at that length. Thanks for insights.

Q3 is a small(-ish) camera+lens with (silent) leaf shutter + optical stabilisation + af + macro; almost pocketable in size & a camera that you can carry in a hip-belt bag/pouch and shoot by one hand as a cell phone, if you wish. The 28Lux-M is rather large & heavy on an M-body. I really enjoy the Q3; but that's just me...

[Pika898]

I would go with the Q3, the lux 28 is a heavy lens and I find the 0.7m limiting for a wide angle, would really benefit from at least a close focus update imo. 

[SiggiGun]

We often see these questions “ x versus y ” in the forum.  My personal answer to this question depends on whether you are a “hard M user” (i.e. you have invested in the M products, which is my case).
1/ You have an M and you have several lenses => 28LUX M
2/ You are more interested in modern technology, autofocus, etc. => Take the Q3 . 
Addition: S3 + Q3 are the modern products and form an excellent “ combo ”. 
 

[costa43]

If you have fallen in love with the Thypoch then I would suggest sticking with that lens and pocketing the cash for another itch.