How to critique images without giving offense.

[jaapv]

Advertisement (gone after registration)

Always remember that the image was posted because the poster found it worthy   Be respectful and constructive 

Always start with the things you like about the image. 

Restrict yourself to improvements to the composition, technical and postprocessing aspects.  
 

Remember that we have photographers of all levels here and that we share a common passion. 

If you want to repost the image with what you think are improvements, seek permission first  

If you respond to critique do so in a factual and non-combative manner Appreciate that somebody took the time to look at your image in-depth and comment on it, even if you disagree completely.

Don't clog up image threads by overly long discussions or going off-topic. They are image threads, after all.

If you don't want your image critiqued, say so when posting it.
 

Above all be respectful. A critique should be an informative experience. 
 That way our forum experience can be enhanced. 
 

[jaapv]

I am moderator on another photoforum which is mainly about critique   I can attest that these guidelines work. Critique has nothing to do with criticism. 
If you don’t want your image to be critiqued just say so in your post. 

[Kl@usW.]

vor 1 Stunde schrieb jaapv:

Always remember that the image was posted because the poster found it worthy   Be respectful and constructive 

Always start with the things you like about the image. 

Restrict yourself to improvements to the composition, technical and postprocessing aspects.  
 

Remember that the we have photographers of all levels here and that we share a common passion. 

If you want to repost the image with what you think are improvements, at least offer to remove on request ( a moderator can do that for you) or seek permission. 
 

Above all be respectful. A critique should be an informative experience. 
 That way our forum experience can be enhanced. 
 

Jaap, absolutely agree with you. However, I think that most violations of these rules are not due to malicious intent, but rather stem from habitual know-it-all behavior and thoughtlessness. People who are used to being right in both their private and professional lives often don't notice their overbearing behavior anymore. Another point that I think is worth mentioning: intercultural differences in the way criticism is given. Lastly, a request (if it hasn't been done yet): please also post these rules in the German section of the forum, perhaps in capital letters.