50 apo vs 50 summarit 2.5

[Crowmagnon]

Advertisement (gone after registration)

As anyone ever tried both of these lenses together. Wondering how's the performance of both of theses at f2.5.

Edited November 7, 2023 by Crowmagnon

[Advertisement]

The Leica Q3 is available for pre-order at B&H Photo Video and Adorama

[newtoleica]

there are plenty of examples of both and reviews on the internet. 

Bottom line, the summarit is plenty sharp, but the rendering of the two lenses is quite different. The summarit is no APO. 

[Photoworks]

You picked 2 extremely opposite lenses in price!

 

[TomB_tx]

The 50 Summarit 2.5 is essentially a half-stop-slower V5 Summicron. I have both and find the images equivalent, but I prefer the handling and smaller size of the 2.5 Summarit

[Crowmagnon]

1 hour ago, Photoworks said:

You picked 2 extremely opposite lenses in price!

 

That's the point how close is the cheapest leica lens to  one of the expensive ones.

[pippy]

47 minutes ago, TomB_tx said:

The 50 Summarit 2.5 is essentially a half-stop-slower V5 Summicron. I have both and find the images equivalent, but I prefer the handling and smaller size of the 2.5 Summarit

Erwin Puts says much the same thing about the performance of those two lenses from f2.8 down, Tom, but the OP is asking about the APO Summicron; not the v5.

Just FWIW and for anyone with five minutes to spare and who might be interested in Herr Puts' comments with regard to the Summarits;

https://photo.imx.nl/leica/lenses/lenses/page83.html

Philip.

[LeicaR10]

Advertisement (gone after registration)

Crowmagnon,   I have used both Leica 50mm lenses with my workshop clients to teach them the optical effects of lens rendering.  Frankly, one would be hard pressed to visually pick which photograph was taken with each lens.  Pippy's post above leads you to a very good essay regarding the Summarit lens line.  If you shoot color and need or want very high optical resolution when used at widest aperture opening with a small rangefinder lens, then a 50 Apo Summicron might be the best choice for you.  Then again, the 50 Summarit either 2.5 or 2.4 versions, will render in most excellent way too.  The good news you have choices.  Here are two links to give you ideas how the two lenses render.  IMO, both are superb.  Last, I always point out to my workshop clients, at the end of the day, it is the content of the photograph that is paramount, not the expense of the camera or lens.    r/ Mark

Try: 50 2.5 https://onfotolife.com/lens_sample_photos?lens_id=371&page=1&focal_min=0&focal_max=800&aperture_min=0&aperture_max=32

Try: 50 2.0 https://onfotolife.com/lens_sample_photos?lens_id=366&page=1&focal_min=0&focal_max=800&aperture_min=0&aperture_max=32

PS  Both lenses are excellent choices especially if you can find a used copy and save on depreciation.

Edited November 8, 2023 by LeicaR10