AA90mm f2 R vs SL mount

[Reddy]

Advertisement (gone after registration)

Hello everyone, 

I'm looking for the APO 90mm f2 asph for my L mount camera, initially I prefer the R AA 90mm f2 as this is a manual lens, then I realise the SL AA 90mm has different formula in the lens design. From my experience the SL AA 50mm f2 is amazing on digital, however I can't put the SL lens on the other M camera like the R mount lens does.

So what is your thought, which one would you keep for the lifetime ? Thanks in advance 

 

Reddy

Edited February 16, 2022 by Reddy

[buj]

I think none of them will keep for lifetime -  therefore you have to buy a M lens... 😉

(i don`t know the R90 mm - but I own a APO SL 90mm for my SL2 and I can say that lens is AWESOME!!)

[Leicaiste]

The 90 R Apo and the 90 M Apo share the same optical design. 

If you intend to use it on both M and SL, the M will be more useful. 

[Reddy]

Thanks Buj and Leicaiste, I have thought about the M version and the price is better of all. However the close focus is at 1m and the manual focus is not as good as the R version if I want it for video. The SL version has AF so surely works best but it is still an electronic lens without aperture manual control. 

Edited February 16, 2022 by Reddy
typo problem

[Sandokan]

I have the R version. Get the SL ... unless you do video. I prefer R to M as it has a longer focus throw but AF (especially with a model) wins

[Reddy]

Thank you Sandokan, that's what I thought, if I have the money I would get both