Jump to content

X1 versus D-Lux 4/D-Lux 5


mhoutman

Recommended Posts

Advertisement (gone after registration)

Being absent for a while I am back again on the forum with a few questions on the X1.

 

My wife currently uses a D-Lux 4 and fell in love with the X1...in black of course ;)

 

1) As the X1 has a bit bigger dimensions I would be interested to have a comparison on portability between the D-Lux's and X1.

 

2) She loves to takes snapshots everywhere. When would she go for a D-Lux 5 and when for a X1 ?

 

3) We have the lovely Artisan & Artist half-case for the D-Lux 4 (with handgrip). Is there a same model for the X1. (I only could find a A & A half case with integrated grip).

 

Thanks for your feedback.

 

Michiel

Link to post
Share on other sites

X1s are a wee big bigger than D-luxs if size is of a serious consideration

 

And yes you can get Artisan cases for them ... with or without Handgrip option.

 

I would recommend Luigis cases , but they are expensive.

 

Brian

Link to post
Share on other sites

Being absent for a while I am back again on the forum with a few questions on the X1.

 

My wife currently uses a D-Lux 4 and fell in love with the X1...in black of course ;) ....

 

2) She loves to takes snapshots everywhere. When would she go for a D-Lux 5 and when for a X1 ?....

Michiel

 

Welcome back Michiel! I think the clue lies in the above quotation, "...She loves to takes snapshots everywhere..." As she is already familiar with the D-Lux 4, she would appreciate the extended zoom range of the D-Lux 5 together with other subtle improvements in image quality.

 

I have both cameras and use both cameras for different purposes. Both are superb, but the D-Lux 5 is rather more versatile (much better macro, for example). The X1 excels with image quality, but for snaps it may be overkill!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Welcome back Michiel! I think the clue lies in the above quotation, "...She loves to takes snapshots everywhere..." As she is already familiar with the D-Lux 4, she would appreciate the extended zoom range of the D-Lux 5 together with other subtle improvements in image quality.

 

I have both cameras and use both cameras for different purposes. Both are superb, but the D-Lux 5 is rather more versatile (much better macro, for example). The X1 excels with image quality, but for snaps it may be overkill!

 

Thanx David (and Brian) for your kind replies :)

 

To be honest I feel the X1 would be a more challenging successor of the D-Lux 4 than buying the D-Lux 5. Besides that It does not always suits me to take my M8 with lens (es) with me, so the X1 would be welcome for me too. Nice excuse to buy these goodies right ?;)

 

So now I have to find an Artisan & Artist black leather half case for X1 with hand grip......

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanx David (and Brian) for your kind replies :)

 

To be honest I feel the X1 would be a more challenging successor of the D-Lux 4 than buying the D-Lux 5. Besides that It does not always suits me to take my M8 with lens (es) with me, so the X1 would be welcome for me too. Nice excuse to buy these goodies right ?;) .....

Are, so you have moved the goal-posts! You didn't say you would use it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I have D-LUX4 and X1, I agree with "wda".

 

  • D-LUX is more versatile (Zoom, Macro, Better AF Tracking and Auto mode)
  • X1 has far better image quality (Better Color and Dynamic Range, Lens Sharpness, etc.) and have Better Access to manual control (Aperture and Shutter Speed Wheel) However, D-LUX image quality is also very good.

 

My suggestion would get X1 because you still have D-LUX4. You can enjoy both D-LUX4 and X1 at the same time. The X1 is light and small enough to carry around.

 

If you get D-LUX5 it is just the same camera as D-LUX4 with some improvements.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Advertisement (gone after registration)

I find that my LX5 and X1 compliment one another really well, so I recommend you get the X1 and keep the D lux 4, unless you absolutley need the longer focal length of the DLux 5. But who among Leica shooters buys a camera for the longer focal length? :)

 

David

Link to post
Share on other sites

Today I ordered in the Netherlands the X1 in black and the grip and bought an Artisan & Artist half case at Red Dot Camera's (Brian thx. for your excellent service).

 

X1 is in back order at the importer's but we love to look forward to this amazing camera. At the time we get it it, it probably has the new firmware :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

X1 is in back order at the importer's but we love to look forward to this amazing camera. At the time we get it it, it probably has the new firmware :)

 

Don't hold your breath on the firmware! You can rest easy in knowing that part of the charm of owning the X1 is "waiting for firmware" just like the Samuel Beckett play.

 

David

Link to post
Share on other sites

Well it's good you know what you are getting in to! Congratulations on the purchase and enjoy your camera when it arrives. There is a forum spot to post X1 shots under "other"..... appropriately designated ;)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thats great Michiel ... look forward to hearing about your X1 :)

I like how the Artisan "handgrip option" has an opening around the red dot.

 

Brian

 

It already arrived that is the case;) Awesome quality and this model is like their D-Lux 4 case

 

Btw also found this M case on the Japanese A&A website. Very nice exept the chrome buttons a bit toommuch Japanese Style ;)

 

http://www.hypebeast.com/image/2010/09/leica-x1-black-0.jpg

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thats great Michiel ... look forward to hearing about your X1 :)

I like how the Artisan "handgrip option" has an opening around the red dot.

 

Brian

 

It already arrived that is the case;) Awesome quality and this model is like their D-Lux 4 case

 

Btw also found this M case on the Japanese A&A website. Very nice exept the chrome buttons a bit toommuch Japanese Style ;)

 

 

http://www.aaa-shop.jp/fs/aaa01/LMB-M9HG

 

 

http://www.aaa-shop.jp/shop/item/aaa01/picture/goods/722_1_expand.jpg

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...