V-Lux 1 vs D-Lux 3 Resolution ?

[chap]

Advertisement (gone after registration)

Am looking at the V-Lux 1 or D-Lux 3 as a backup to M8 but curious about final resolution. Reported numbers are:

 

V-Lux 1

4:3 Aspect Ratio 3648 x 2736 2560 x 1920 2048 x 1536 1600 x 1200

3:2 Aspect Ratio 3600 x 2400 3248 x 2160 2560 x 1712 2048 x 1360

16:9 Aspect Ratio 3584 x 2016 3072 x 1728 1920 x 1080 (HDTV standard)

 

D-Lux 3

4:3 format 3168 x 2376 2880 x 2160 2304 x 1728 2048 x 1536 1600 x 1200 1280 x 960

3:2 format 3568 x 2376 3248 x 2160 2560 x 1712 2048 x 1360

16:9 format 4224 x 2376 3840 x 2160 3072 x 1728 1920 x 1080

 

Appears to me that the V-Lux has better resolution in 4:3 aspect ratio, cameras are equivalent at 3:2 aspect ratio, and the D-Lux has better resolution at 16:9 aspect ratio.

 

How should one evaluate the two relative to final image quality (ignoring size, weight, zoom and other physical differences that are more a matter of personal preference)?

 

Which will produce the best quality file for enlargement at 11 x 14?