Jump to content

Test results: which of 21 Leica M lenses can cover 44x33 (Hasselblad X) sensors?


onasj

Recommended Posts

Advertisement (gone after registration)

Here are results of testing 21 Leica M lenses for their ability to cover the medium format 44x33 mm sensor of a Hasselblad X camera.  I used a CFV-ii-50c back, a 907x, and a Novoflex LEM to HAX adapter, but I assume that these results will hold for other camera systems that also use the Sony IMX161 50 MP 44x33 mm sensor, including both Fuji GFX 50 cameras and both Hasselblad X1D cameras.

In general, don't expect that any Leica M lens will perfectly cover an entire medium format sensor with no vignetting—even the "cropped" 44x33 mm sensor.  Of course most of these lenses don't even cover a 36x24 mm sensor without at least some vignetting.  Some lenses come very close though, and are more than usable to produce excellent images.  As a general rule, you will see less vignetting at close focusing distances than at infinity, and you will see less vignetting at moderate apertures (around f/2.8, typically) than at very large apertures or very small apertures.

"NO" means dark corners are present at any focusing distance or any aperture—that is, the lens's image circle does not cover the entire sensor.

"YES" means there might be some vignetting or, less common, some purple color shift in the corners, but you can get the subject image to cover the entire sensor.  I provide notes to explain each YES when appropriate.

The version of each of the 21 lenses below is the *most recently produced version*, even though some (like the Stemar, the 50/2.8, and the 75/1.4) are no longer in production.  The results may differ if you use an older version of the same lens since the optical formulae of many Leica M lenses changed as new versions were produced.

 

WATE at 16 or 18 mm: NO

*WATE at 21 mm: YES, some vignetting

21/3.4: NO

24/3.8: NO

28/1.4: NO

28/2: YES, but with strong vignetting especially at or near infinity, and at wide apertures

28/2.8: YES, but with strong vignetting and purple corners

Stemar: YES, but the divider produces some artifacts at top of the frame.  Still, it's very cool to generate 3-D stereo image pairs using this old Leica lens and a current medium-format sensor!

MATE at 28: NO

MATE at 50: YES, but only at near distances

MATE at 35: YES, but with strong vignetting at the very corners

35/1.4: YES at closer distances or apertures around f/2.8, with some color shift

*35/2: YES, with some vignetting

50/0.95: NO

*50/1.4: YES, with only slight vignetting at infinity

50/2 APO: YES, but only between f/3.5-6.3

*50/2.8: YES, a little vignetting wide open at infinity

*75/1.25: YES, slight vignetting at infinity 

75/1.4: YES, but only around f/2.8 and at close distances

*75/2 APO: YES, almost perfect until f/8, only slight vignetting

*90/2 APO: YES, with only slight vignetting

90/2.4: YES, but only at mid/near distances

90/4: NO

135/3.4 APO: NO

Overall, the lenses I marked with an asterisk are the most useable: the WATE at 21 mm, the 35/2, 50/1.4, 50/2.8, 75/1.25, 75 APO, and 90 APO.  Which is really a not a bad outfit if your goal is to shoot your small Leica M lenses on a cropped medium format sensor at a range of focal lengths. 

  • Like 7
  • Thanks 7
Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, onasj said:

You set the Hasselblad camera or back to electronic shutter.  So if your subject is prone to rolling shutter artifacts, you are best using Hasselblad lenses or a Leica camera.

Ah, that's the trick!  everyone I asked they go "NO!" 

We cannot use flash neither without shutter so all studio works are no go. 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...

Advertisement (gone after registration)

This is really very helpful, thank you.

I am currently pondering a lens kit selection for a return to using the M system after some time away. I also have a 907X and 4/45P on the way already, and was wondering about the dual use possibilities for some M glass. The 50APO and 50SX are on my shortlist - each has its strengths and characteristics on the M, but it is interesting that the 50SX (and related 75APO) offer better coverage than the 50APO. 90APO I am not surprised works well, but I was surprised to read that the 135APO didn't work out. That's a pity. Interesting that 35SN worked better than 35SX. 

So, thank you once again. 

Are you finding in practice that you are actually using any of your M lenses on the 907X, or are you mostly sticking with XCD glass @onasj?

Link to post
Share on other sites

50 minutes ago, Winedemonium said:

This is really very helpful, thank you.

I am currently pondering a lens kit selection for a return to using the M system after some time away. I also have a 907X and 4/45P on the way already, and was wondering about the dual use possibilities for some M glass. The 50APO and 50SX are on my shortlist - each has its strengths and characteristics on the M, but it is interesting that the 50SX (and related 75APO) offer better coverage than the 50APO. 90APO I am not surprised works well, but I was surprised to read that the 135APO didn't work out. That's a pity. Interesting that 35SN worked better than 35SX. 

So, thank you once again. 

Are you finding in practice that you are actually using any of your M lenses on the 907X, or are you mostly sticking with XCD glass @onasj?

XCD glass is outstanding in general and AF is useful so I’m mostly shooting with XCD lenses. But if I wanted a focal length not in my XCD lenses or a larger aperture, I wouldn’t hesitate to use those Leica M lenses in my original post.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 4 months later...
On 1/10/2021 at 3:07 AM, frame-it said:

Hmmm.. I got some pronounced vignetting at 4:3 on both the Voigtlander 40mm f1.2 and the Leica R 90mm, the latter going black in the corners, both of which this spreadsheet indicates as green.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...