Please vote here / Bitte hier Abstimmen

[farnz]

Advertisement (gone after registration)

Here are the rules for voting:

You have until 19th of March to cast your vote as follows.
Three points for best, two points for second and one point for third.
Voting runs for two weeks. One vote per member and, of course, no voting for your own image.

The winner takes responsibility for setting the theme for the next Barnack Challenge.

 

 

-----------------------------------------------------

 

 

Hier die Regeln fürs Abstimmen:

Ihr habt bis zum 19 März Zeit, die Eurer Meinung nach besten Bilder zu wählen. Dazu verteilt Ihr
drei Punkte für das beste Bild, zwei für das zweitbeste und einen für das drittplatzierte.
Die Abstimmung läuft zwei Wochen Eine Stimme pro Forumsmitglied, das eigene Bild darf nicht gewählt werden.

Der Gewinner erhält die Verantwortung, das Thema für die nächste Barnack Challenge festzulegen.



 

[Advertisement]

Hallo,

Look here: Interesting Leica gear

[christoph_d]

Thanks Pete, 

 

Here's my vote, which on a different day may well have been different; great work all of you:

 

3 points for Doug A with "Tones at the push of a button"

2 points for Bateleur with "Wired for sound" 

1 point for robert_parker with "street tones" 

 

Regards

 

C.

[Suuumm55]

Hello everybody,

 

3 points > Bateleur

2 points > mnutzer

1 point   > Keith (M)

[robert_parker]

Challenging to decide because the entries are so good.

 

1)  Erl - Leaning Tones of melbourne - 3 points

 

2)  Mnutzer - Tones of the Past

 

3)  Bateleur - Wired for Sound

 

Regards from Burnham on Sea

Robert

[hartgraef]

Hello!

My vote:

3 pts ... Doug A

2 pts ... erl

1 pt ..... mnutzer

Edited March 6, 2017 by hartgraef

[Dan Bachmann]

3 pts - Doug A - At the push of a button

2 pts - mdach - Loud Work Tones

1 pt - Robert Parker - Street Tones

[erl]

Advertisement (gone after registration)

#4 - 3 pts  Doug A

 

#1 - 2 pts  Keith M

 

# 7 - 1 pt  Farnz

 

Damn good entries all round.

Awarding 1st, second and third is not indicative of the overall standard. Other entries, IMO, deserve equal merit.

 

OUTTAKES

I have started a thread for Outtakes from this current Barnack Challenge.

http://www.l-camera-forum.com/topic/270109-barnack-challenge-tones-tones-tones-outtakes/

Please feel free to add your outtakes so we can enjoy your selection process.

[Advertisement]

Hallo,

Look here: Interesting Leica gear

[ejd]

1st 3 points  Doug A Tones at the push of a button
2nd 2 points mnutzer tones of the past
3rd 1 point Keith(M) Tones on the landscape

[octo]

#9 = 3 pts

#7 = 2 pts

#12 = 1 pt

 

Well done all!

[mdachs]

Bateleur 3pts

Doug A  2pts

Farnz    1pt

 

 

 

Rgds

Joachim

[mnutzer]

...

You have until 19th of March to cast your vote as follows.

...

 

∙  3 pts.  #12  erl  “Leaning Tones of Melbourne”  ∙

 

∙  2 pts.  #13  thomas_schertel  “My tones to be made”  ∙

 

∙  1 pt.  #09  robert_parker  “Street Tones”  ∙

[Bateleur]

After agonizing over the pictures for there more worthy entries than I have votes, may I commit these as my choice

 

3 pts.  #4    douga

2 pts.  #13  thomas_schertel

1 pt.    #3    mdachs

[muellerman779]

Earl - 3P

Keith - 2P

Doug - 1P

[thomas_schertel]

Keith                 3 pts

Doug A               2 pts

erl                       1 pt

[Doug A]

mdachs - 3 pts

 

mnutzer - 2 pts

 

farnz - 1 pt

[Advertisement]

Hallo,

Look here: Interesting Leica gear

[farnz]

Voting is now closed.

 

Thank you to everyone who voted but a special note of thanks to everyone who took part and entered a picture.  The standard of entries was very high and it was very pleasing to see such a wide and varied interpretation of the topic.

 

The results:

 

First place with 23 votes .............. #4 "Tones at the push of a button." by Doug A

 

Second place with 13 votes ......... #12 "Leaning Tones of Melbourne." by erl

 

Third equal place with 9 votes ...... #6 by Bataleur, #11 by mnutzer, and #1 by Keith M.

 

Congratulations to the place-getters for their excellent entries but especially to Doug A who is the winner and who has the responsibility for running the next Barnack Challenge in about 3 months time.

 

Pete.

[erl]

I can only echo Petes comments and congratulate Doug A on the 'tone' of his winning entry.

Hello guest!
Please register or sign in to view the hidden content.

Also very well done to Bataleur and mnutzer an Keith M for such a close duel with each other.

IMO, all entries are worthy and speaking for myself, participating is the reward.

Thanks to Pete for organizing it.

[robert_parker]

I agree - thanks to Pete for organising the challenge and congratulations to Doug A for an excellent and well deserved win

 

I'll look forward to the next challenge (especialy if it features Toads....)

Hello guest!
Please register or sign in to view the hidden content.

Edited March 21, 2017 by robert_parker

[Suuumm55]

Congratulations to the winners 
And not least congratulations to all who have given their best here

 

 

Hello guest!
Please register or sign in to view the hidden content.

[Bateleur]

Congratulations Doug for the winning photograph! And thank you to Pete for a thought provoking topic!

 

Looking forward to the next challenge.

 

Regards

Charles

Edited March 22, 2017 by Bateleur