View Single Post
Old 30.12.2008, 05:50   #23 (permalink)
sdai
Erfahrener Benutzer
 
Join Date: 05.03.2004
Posts: 3,239
Default Re: MTF charts for first four S lenses

Considering the 1.25x conversion factor, a 35mm on the S2 is equivalent to a 28mm on the M7 for an identical view angle so I did a quick dirty comparison between the 28mm Summicron-M and the 35mm f/2.5 CS by overlaying the MTF charts of both lenses at f/2.5(f/2.8) and f/5.6.

Blue lines are for the 35-S and red lines are for the 28-M-Cron, horizontal axis of the M lens has been scaled to about 74% of the S lens horizontal axis so you can see the M lens edges at 20mm and the S lens edges at 27mm.

Performance wise, they are almost identical in terms of contrast, resolution at f/2.5(f/2.8) are quite similar, the S lens has an edge in resolution at f/5.6 ... but that's not a surprise if the test target is the same, at an identical view angle the larger format lens of the same optical quality is bound to produce some higher resolution numbers.

A brand new 28 Summicron-M ASPH. is asking for US$4000, adding auto focus and a leaf shutter for larger format, how much would you bet on the 35/2.5 S lens?

I'm guessing its price would be around $6000-$8000 US, adding the cost of the body, 15000 Euros at least (based on reports from the Kina '08) - roughly 21500 US$ ... that's about US$30000 to kick start.

Must be the best bang of your bucks ... when I hit the powerball jackpot, I will also jump on board.
Attached Images
File Type: jpg 28M-35S.jpg (125.4 KB, 168 views)

Last edited by sdai; 30.12.2008 at 06:03.
sdai is offline   Reply With Quote