View Single Post
Old 08/06/08, 11:28 PM   #1 (permalink)
bill
Erfahrener Benutzer
 
bill's Avatar
 
Join Date: 01/27/03
Location: Frimley
Posts: 2,626
Default An unedifying experience and a realisation

Now, before I start, I should point out that this is not a Voigtlander-bashing thread. I think they make some splendid lenses, and have revitalised the rangefinder market.

But.

Some of you will remember that I dipped my toe into the RF-digital waters with an RD-1s. I kept it a few months then sold it on. No matter how I tried, I could not warm to it. I put it down to a digital thing - it bruised my workflow, and I just didn't enjoy using it. I am happy, by the way, using Olympus digital SLRs but that is a different experience altogether.

So, to my point. I recently acquired a Bessa R as a "high tech" body for my LTM lenses. Much as I love my IID, not all my screwmount lenses sit comfortably on it and I thought that a more "conventional" Bessa body would make a good backup, and occasional user.

I have just returned from a short break in Riva del Garda. A beautiful location, photogenic and easy on the eye. I took my IID and the Bessa R, with a small selection of lenses (yes really), intending to use the Leica as usual for black and white, and the Voigtlander for colour. It was the first time I had used it, leisure time being a bit of a luxury these days.

I was sorely disappointed in the Bessa. There was no one thing that made it a bad camera, but just so many things that, put together, made it not nice to use. In no particular order they were:

1. Balance - the Bessa hangs from it's strap lugs pointing skywards with anything other than the heaviest lenses.

2. Film advance - notchy and agricultural, and impossible to "inch" like an M.

3. RF patch flareout - unless your eye is exactly in the right position, the patch disappears.

4. Manual frame selection - ok, I know I should know better, but I misframed three or four times because I simply forgot to switch over.

5. Handling - I just cannot warm to the proportions of the Voigtlander body. It feels too tall to me, out of proportion to it's width and thickness.

I know this is all a very personal thing, but it just isn't a Leica. It's a camera in it's own right, I know, but just so unedifying to use. I haven't even developed the images I took with it, but I already know there are no real keepers. My mood, my eye, were affected by the experience. I ended up shooting far more than I expected with the IID, even loading it with colour film rather than go on using the Bessa.

The realisation? I think it is actually twofold. Firstly, it wasn't the digital-ness of the RD-1 that I disliked all those months ago, it was the Bessa-ness.

Secondly, Leica, in M and screwmount forms, simply is as good as it gets in terms of handling and user enjoyment. Anything else just doesn't come close.

Regards,

Bill
__________________
Bill Palmer (Gentleman Amateur and Leica Lout)
________________________________
"God is not on the side of the big battalions, but on the side of those who shoot best."
12 of my best
Some of my images
bill is offline   Reply With Quote